refresp-pr
                                                             revised 11/01

**************************************************************************

Physical Review - REFEREE RESPONSE FORM - Electronic mail version

Insert X in the parentheses in the response form as appropriate.

PLEASE RETURN YOUR ENTIRE RESPONSE (this form and your referee report) AS
ONE FILE to the appropriate email address:  pra, prb, prc, prd, pre, prst-ab, or
prst-per@aps.org --- Give as the subject "report" followed by the manuscript
code number and the last name of the first author; for example, "report
AB1234 Smith" or "report ab1234 smith".  If you do not receive an 
acknowledgment within one working day, please repeat the message or send
the report via another mode.  Do not automatically follow an electronic-
mail report with a backup by conventional mail.  Thank you for your help.

**************************************************************************

   Referee:

   Manuscript Number:

   Author:

   Title:


1.  Please summarize your assessment of the paper:

                                                           YES  MAYBE   NO
    Does the paper contain enough significant new physics
    to warrant publication in the Physical Review?         ( )   ( )   ( )
    Is the paper scientifically sound and not misleading?  ( )   ( )   ( )
    Is the paper well organized and clearly written?       ( )   ( )   ( )
    Are the subject matter and style of presentation
    appropriate for the Physical Review?                   ( )   ( )   ( )
    Is the length appropriate?                             ( )   ( )   ( )

2.  Please evaluate quality of Research and Presentation:
                                 (  ) Excellent (  )
                                 (  ) Good      (  )
                                 (  ) Average   (  )
                                 (  ) Marginal  (  )
                                 (  ) Poor      (  )

3.  Recommendation:
 (  ) Publish without change (please give reasons in report).
 (  ) Publish after authors have considered the optional revisions mentioned
      in the report.
 (  ) Publish after authors have made the revisions mentioned in the report.
      (I do not need to see the manuscript again.)
 (  ) Revisions are necessary. Return to me on resubmittal.
 (  ) Revisions are necessary. On resubmittal, send to:

                (Use as much space as needed to list
                 names of alternative reviewers.)
 (  ) Manuscript is more appropriate for another 
                                 (  ) journal (specify): 
                              or (  ) section (specify):
 (  ) Do not publish; see report.             
 (  ) Other; see report.         

************************************************************************
begin_report (use as much space as is needed):


end_report
************************************************************************